Compiled List of Suggestions For Redbana - Redbana Forums

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Compiled List of Suggestions For Redbana

Collapse
This is a sticky topic.
X
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Chomby
    started a topic Compiled List of Suggestions For Redbana

    Compiled List of Suggestions For Redbana

    I am not done listing yet. Work in progress
    I've compiled a list of suggestions for redbana and to have a general thread where everyone can see what suggestions have already been presented to redbana.

    I know there are one or two other threads like this, but this one includes both glitches that need to get fixed and suggestions from the users. I will be updating this weekly.

    Not all of these on here should be implemented, or am I suggesting they should be. But they have been presented by other users, and should be documented as so.

    General Problems
    The Token System - The token system has been broken for over a year now I believe. Could we get this fixed?
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=49095
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=43298

    Windows 8 - Windows 8 and Audition are currently not compatible. Fix Please when you can?
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=62898
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=62801
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=62964
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=62866
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=62820

    Medal Glitches (Couples vs Ballroom) - Currently Couple Tournament and Ballroom Tournament have the same medal. Couples should be the heart, and ballroom should be a flower icon for the girls, and a top hat for the boys.
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=50926

    Clock In Game - CURRENTLY IN SYNC WITH REAL TIME YAY
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=63171



    Replays - Replays have been broken for a long time. It's mostly a disconnection issue and possibly has to do with Xtrap.
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=62746

    Flushing of inactive accounts - A lot of people are holding IGNs on level one accounts. League of Legends just flushed all level six accounts and under for IGNs and I don't see why we can't do this either, especially since it's such a big problem on this server.
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=61448
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=59467
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=60434
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=66598
    Offbeat Songs - Fix them? Maybe. Please?
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=62432
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=58537
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=53952

    Randomization of Songs - It has been recognized by the players on this server that the randomization of songs for tournaments is favoring certain songs, and have recurring paterns. This needs to get fixed.
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=62493
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=62699

    Experience / Tournaments
    Medal Glitches - Currently Guitar Medal dissappears if you have more than one medal when you recieve it. Upon losing the other medal you had, you also lose guitar, whether or not the 24 hour period is up.
    - Me winning guitar: http://forums.redbana.com/microsuppo...1355460115.jpg
    - Me with three medals: http://forums.redbana.com/microsuppo...1355398459.jpg
    - Me losing medal after 2 or 3 hours (Because I lost my couple medal): http://forums.redbana.com/microsuppo...1355459336.jpg
    I couldn't find a thread for this one.

    Medal Glitches (x2 Experience Bonus) - Currently we only recieve a bonus for Expert and Guitar tournament medals. It has been suggested we get a x2 bonus for other modes, and a heart bonus for Couple and Ballroom Tournaments.
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=47965
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=47540

    Expert Channel - Currently our Expert Channel, is a special channel (the event sever) we get when Redbana decides to feel nice and give us a channel that gives us an experience boost. This should be a permanent channel available for use all the time.
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=45687
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=33611
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=25517

    X2 Experience Events - SEA does this. They'll have x2 experience for a week every now and then. Similar to when they increase drops in other games. It would be nice, especially since its so hard to level on this server because we lack other experience boosts.
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=55806

    Option to turn off experience cards
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=65968

    Team Tournament - Team tournament time and number of teams required has been a long standing problem. It's during Expert tournmanet and does not get enough teams to start. I believe the Requirement is 8 teams currently? Which should be lowered. People hold the team medal for months.
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=61601
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=47559
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=56494
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=64185

    1-2 Party Tournament - Probably won't happen, but we can dream.
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=29901
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=8797

    Tournament Glitch - It always says for the [winner's name here], [mode] is the winner!

    Forums / Website
    Banning System - I know a few people agree with me on this, the banning system and support ticket system is flawed. Our harassment policy is flawed (mostly the way cases are investigated and what kind of sanctions are given). Currently the ones being banned can not see the evidence presented against them, nor give evidence to defend themselves. The ticket system is slow and usually unhelpful based on my own experiences and those of a few others.
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=62928

    Referal System - A lot of other games have some type of refferal system. It would be nice if we could have one implemented.
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=62687

    Thanks Button (And other additional Features)
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=60086
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=57505
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=65852
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=66202
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=65289

    New Website Layout - This is for redbana.com, not forums. I think the current website could be improved a lot personally, and so do others.
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=62239
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=41319
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=37977

    Animated Signatures - Could cause a lot of lag on forums, but a cool idea in theory.
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=60132

    Closable threads - Author of thread should be able to close it
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=59861

    Download Option (Not Torrent)- It would be nice if there was an easy to get to download of Audition that wasn't through torrent
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=52535
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=54785

    List of Issues Being Addressed - This is self explainatory. There should be some form of updating on current issues and it should be updated weekly. Especially things like the Windows 8 Problem. We need a list of things they are currently working on, so things dont get reported or suggested more than necessary.
    - http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=60464
    Last edited by Chomby; 06-28-2013, 01:26 AM.

  • Makoto
    replied
    Originally posted by Hengbok View Post
    whether the ones who want to believe HellQueen or not, she is actually the one making most sense relating to the majority of her topics regarding this (yes that's even the replies she made on older threads too).

    But yes, ideas and suggestions that are made do get looked at. Just like with anything else, do not assume things are not being done just because you(the general audience) are not getting "updates" on every single suggestion. Some things as we all have noticed can take what seems like forever and some things maybe sooner than others. Suggestions that are made also do not mean that they will happen either. That's why they are suggestions(although some are bogus lol).

    They have always been hinting at certain things as well that people asked for but save the surprise for when a patch is released, but I do not think the GM's would like to let people know if something also cannot be implemented because maybe someday it can(like the indefinite items which was said it wouldn't be) but you never know. That's something the company will decide and there are things that they know about and will handle for whatever reason they feel needed.

    There is a reason for their decisions or what is being done and is in no way of trying to frustrate a player. If anyone wants to get some updates on various topics regarding some issues or suggestions, you can read up on the Community Agent blogs as they will address some topics that were mentioned. If you do not like to read and would rather listen then there is also a video blog summarizing the blog as well. http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=62860

    Siou gave a couple examples which are even things some probably didn't even know how helped other servers thanks to this one(especially with the help of reports from the community about various issues). I would at least think everyone would want to play the game with a bug free environment as well.
    but if some of the people who are complaining about nothing being done that do not want to take the time to use the search button to either remember or find out what they have missed being done before then do not post your negative feedback for the sole purpose of trying to be negative. You can leave negative feedbacks but do not make it seem like they have not been doing anything just because not everything has happened.

    Last thing we need for good input is a constant negative nancy(not literally any people named nancy lol) that doesn't look at it from both sides or try to be fair about what's being brought up. Like many have mentioned, it is a business and they do what's best for them and also at the same time trying to give the best for everyone on this server.


    PS: This is going to be the only warning to make sure that everyone is to stay on topic of this thread or else there will be a mass cleaning that will only have suggestions people feel maybe should be added to the list and no space for arguments among each other. If this continues to be a problem then it may be where the thread tgfcoder made will still stay open and people can just bring their attention there as it can still be updated.
    I don't feel like reading the your entire post, but I read the top and the bottom

    @B: What you think =/= what everyone else should think. Just because you believe it doesn't mean what she's saying is true and should be for everyone else and it's no surprise that you're agreeing here either


    @U: The arguing wouldn't be as severe if she didn't antagonize people that don't agree with her. Apparently if you aren't on her side = you're automatically stupid

    her google research works wonders

    Leave a comment:


  • Chomby
    replied
    Originally posted by Hengbok View Post
    whether the ones who want to believe HellQueen or not, she is actually the one making most sense relating to the majority of her topics regarding this (yes that's even the replies she made on older threads too).

    But yes, ideas and suggestions that are made do get looked at. Just like with anything else, do not assume things are not being done just because you(the general audience) are not getting "updates" on every single suggestion. Some things as we all have noticed can take what seems like forever and some things maybe sooner than others. Suggestions that are made also do not mean that they will happen either. That's why they are suggestions(although some are bogus lol).

    They have always been hinting at certain things as well that people asked for but save the surprise for when a patch is released, but I do not think the GM's would like to let people know if something also cannot be implemented because maybe someday it can(like the indefinite items which was said it wouldn't be) but you never know. That's something the company will decide and there are things that they know about and will handle for whatever reason they feel needed.

    There is a reason for their decisions or what is being done and is in no way of trying to frustrate a player. If anyone wants to get some updates on various topics regarding some issues or suggestions, you can read up on the Community Agent blogs as they will address some topics that were mentioned. If you do not like to read and would rather listen then there is also a video blog summarizing the blog as well. http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=62860

    Siou gave a couple examples which are even things some probably didn't even know how helped other servers thanks to this one(especially with the help of reports from the community about various issues). I would at least think everyone would want to play the game with a bug free environment as well.
    but if some of the people who are complaining about nothing being done that do not want to take the time to use the search button to either remember or find out what they have missed being done before then do not post your negative feedback for the sole purpose of trying to be negative. You can leave negative feedbacks but do not make it seem like they have not been doing anything just because not everything has happened.

    Last thing we need for good input is a constant negative nancy(not literally any people named nancy lol) that doesn't look at it from both sides or try to be fair about what's being brought up. Like many have mentioned, it is a business and they do what's best for them and also at the same time trying to give the best for everyone on this server.


    PS: This is going to be the only warning to make sure that everyone is to stay on topic of this thread or else there will be a mass cleaning that will only have suggestions people feel maybe should be added to the list and no space for arguments among each other. If this continues to be a problem then it may be where the thread tgfcoder made will still stay open and people can just bring their attention there as it can still be updated.
    I put a lot of work into this and I don't think it's fair to punish me for the arguments that have been happening on this thread. Especially since I've asked them not to. Tgfcoder's list and mine are not the same.

    In all honesty I've hoped these discussions on here have helped people see the PoV of the company and frustrated players, and anyone with their head on their shoulders can make a thought out opinion for themselves on how good of a job Redbana is doing and why all these features (Some necessary, some unecessary) have or have not been implemented.

    Feel free to clean the thread up, but don't close it.

    Leave a comment:


  • Hengbok
    replied
    whether the ones who want to believe HellQueen or not, she is actually the one making most sense relating to the majority of her topics regarding this (yes that's even the replies she made on older threads too).

    But yes, ideas and suggestions that are made do get looked at. Just like with anything else, do not assume things are not being done just because you(the general audience) are not getting "updates" on every single suggestion. Some things as we all have noticed can take what seems like forever and some things maybe sooner than others. Suggestions that are made also do not mean that they will happen either. That's why they are suggestions(although some are bogus lol).

    They have always been hinting at certain things as well that people asked for but save the surprise for when a patch is released, but I do not think the GM's would like to let people know if something also cannot be implemented because maybe someday it can(like the indefinite items which was said it wouldn't be) but you never know. That's something the company will decide and there are things that they know about and will handle for whatever reason they feel needed.

    There is a reason for their decisions or what is being done and is in no way of trying to frustrate a player. If anyone wants to get some updates on various topics regarding some issues or suggestions, you can read up on the Community Agent blogs as they will address some topics that were mentioned. If you do not like to read and would rather listen then there is also a video blog summarizing the blog as well. http://forums.redbana.com/showthread.php?t=62860

    Siou gave a couple examples which are even things some probably didn't even know how helped other servers thanks to this one(especially with the help of reports from the community about various issues). I would at least think everyone would want to play the game with a bug free environment as well.
    but if some of the people who are complaining about nothing being done that do not want to take the time to use the search button to either remember or find out what they have missed being done before then do not post your negative feedback for the sole purpose of trying to be negative. You can leave negative feedbacks but do not make it seem like they have not been doing anything just because not everything has happened.

    Last thing we need for good input is a constant negative nancy(not literally any people named nancy lol) that doesn't look at it from both sides or try to be fair about what's being brought up. Like many have mentioned, it is a business and they do what's best for them and also at the same time trying to give the best for everyone on this server.


    PS: This is going to be the only warning to make sure that everyone is to stay on topic of this thread or else there will be a mass cleaning that will only have suggestions people feel maybe should be added to the list and no space for arguments among each other. If this continues to be a problem then it may be where the thread tgfcoder made will still stay open and people can just bring their attention there as it can still be updated.

    Leave a comment:


  • xantoniax
    replied
    same sex marriage and gifting plox.

    Leave a comment:


  • CeresChii
    replied
    Originally posted by HellQueen View Post
    That's like walking into McDonalds asking for a Whopper and then complaining that the restaurant sucks because they don't have what you want.
    We need to make this an official analogy when people complain LOL

    I won't say I've always been on Redbana's side since I was pretty mad when they temp banned me durin that hacker phase, but they did get my account back & they are updating x-trap more to get to of hackers so I'm pretty fine with it now.

    I guess since I don't play other servers I'm fine with Redbana, but I still think they're doing fine in terms of patches & updates.

    Leave a comment:


  • HellQueen
    replied
    Originally posted by Gasai Yuno View Post
    lmao, wtf is this? First of all, if I didn't care about the game or want it to succeed, I wouldn't be making suggestions at all, and I sure as hell wouldn't be spending money buying their cash lol

    The problem isn't what we don't have. It isn't "crybabys not getting what they want" either. The problem, or at least my problem since you called me out, is that the suggestions don't get forwarded and/or seriously reviewed. The GMs just say "oh, that looks like it will be hard but we'll get back to you" and leave it alone. Lol. Redbana has been open for almost 4 years, there's like a thousand threads in the feedback & suggestion section, and the only things people can say that they've done are "fix" somebugs, add x3 exp and den, and blahblahblah about the bu charts." Oh, they've also added some indefinite items to shut people up. Great, that's fine, and if you haven't noticed, I give them credit where credit is due.
    On the other hand though, the majority of suggestion posts made by the community are seen only by the gms and not by people who could actually make them happen.



    don't speak for "most of the community" lol. Do you even play this game actively? If you go into the game and ask people what they think about Redbana and how they've run Audition so far, most of the comments will be negative, or indifferent because they don't care about these things.


    On-topic though, this is a nice thread, maybe something will actually come out of it since it got stickied.
    Do you even have the slightest idea what other gaming companies are like? Have you ever actually actively played anything but Audition, because I highly doubt it. Like actually, your ignorance is starting to annoy me.

    @Bold there are MILLIONS of suggestions/comments/ideas whatever on literally EVERY game. Generally 95% of the suggestions made by a gaming community on any game is ignored. I'm pretty sure Redbana actively is part of the community way more than any other gaming company I've ever seen. And I'm on a lot of gaming communities.

    @Red You don't know that, don't talk about stuff you clearly don't know. I mean you hardly know how the game itself and the company works so I don't think you have any rights or means to make an educated guess.

    @Underline I wasn't speaking for the community I was observing, I don't play this game actively anymore, but I'm a top gamer on many games, I can hold my own in Audition as well as anyone else, and have a clear understanding about how games actually work. Most people go on Redbana and complain because they look at other servers and try to do a comparison. That's just not going to work. Redbana is not another server, we're smaller, more poor, and we get less backup from T3 then the other servers. Like SiouX said earlier, if you want to leave then leave, but don't go around acting like the game sucks so much just because we don't have "special features" that aren't even necessary. That's like walking into McDonalds asking for a Whopper and then complaining that the restaurant sucks because they don't have what you want.

    And like, this game is literally pressing arrows and then space, it's also free, I don't get how people can expect so much out of it.

    [youtube]TbT-cW8Zb7o[/youtube]

    Kinda relevant lol, what would happen to Audi if we put it in the hands of our players...
    Last edited by HellQueen; 12-30-2012, 01:48 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • white girl is white
    replied
    Originally posted by --No View Post
    what andrea said

    i'm looking at you john and sunny
    lmao, wtf is this? First of all, if I didn't care about the game or want it to succeed, I wouldn't be making suggestions at all, and I sure as hell wouldn't be spending money buying their cash lol

    The problem isn't what we don't have. It isn't "crybabys not getting what they want" either. The problem, or at least my problem since you called me out, is that the suggestions don't get forwarded and/or seriously reviewed. The GMs just say "oh, that looks like it will be hard but we'll get back to you" and leave it alone. Lol. Redbana has been open for almost 4 years, there's like a thousand threads in the feedback & suggestion section, and the only things people can say that they've done are "fix some bugs, add x3 exp and den, and blahblahblah about the bu charts." Oh, they've also added some indefinite items to shut people up. Great, that's fine, and if you haven't noticed, I give them credit where credit is due.
    On the other hand though, the majority of suggestion posts made by the community are seen only by the gms and not by people who could actually make them happen.

    Originally posted by HellQueen View Post
    I'm glad most of the community is starting to understand the companies PoV. Though some other people are still in their corner of denial just because they aren't getting their way.

    Just to note I've always defended Redbana on matters like this!
    don't speak for "most of the community" lol. Do you even play this game actively? If you go into the game and ask people what they think about Redbana and how they've run Audition so far, most of the comments will be negative, or indifferent because they don't care about these things.


    On-topic though, this is a nice thread, maybe something will actually come out of it since it got stickied.
    Last edited by white girl is white; 12-30-2012, 10:32 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Makoto
    replied
    Originally posted by Fae View Post







    I am confused o-o
    The first half was talking about a matter that was off topic to the subject at hand. But the second half was about how they always say "we will send this to our superiors" when they never do.

    Whenever they reply to a suggestion thread, they say that, and there's no more word about it after that. The thing is, they don't send it. Also, not every suggestion needs to be processed through T3 either. If they sent it all to their superiors, I'm sure some of the requests would happen. But they don't

    T3 does custom requests for other servers, even the awful ones, but yet Redbana apparently gets denied constantly. Like wth? T3 doesn't want to see one of their servers flopping if they don't have to

    and when I say "but nothing has" I'm talking about recently, not in all
    -
    the second post was saying that she only had two things to show for their progress, and those two things were just sad....the bugs that get reported are mostly small and unnecessary to fix. And the BU songs are nothing to brag about and that was done a long time ago too
    -
    the third post was saying that they can do as many small, irrelevant things as they want to, but they're forgetting to do the essential things, which have been said and pointed out to them for the longest.
    Last edited by Hengbok; 12-30-2012, 06:33 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Chomby
    replied
    Originally posted by HellQueen View Post
    I'm glad most of the community is starting to understand the companies PoV. Though some other people are still in their corner of denial just because they aren't getting their way. *cough*

    Just to note I've always defended Redbana on matters like this!
    I can't stress enough that Redbana is a company. They can't go around doing as they please, they have to go through X amount of people to get something implemented or done. And they need a much larger player base if we want to see some of these suggestions getting taken seriously. Which is why I think a referal system could really help. Instead of complaining we need to be proactive in getting the game out there, getting a larger playerbase (more income) for Redbana and then we can finally start seeing some changes that a lot of people hope to see.

    Leave a comment:


  • HellQueen
    replied
    I'm glad most of the community is starting to understand the companies PoV. Though some other people are still in their corner of denial just because they aren't getting their way.

    Just to note I've always defended Redbana on matters like this!
    Last edited by Hengbok; 12-30-2012, 06:37 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Oddbrother
    replied
    Originally posted by Fae View Post
    I am confused o-o
    I think he's saying all they've ever been doing is sweating the small stuff and ignoring/overlooking the big picture.

    Leave a comment:


  • Fae
    replied
    Originally posted by Ricardo View Post
    her logic is "is they don't say it, it's not true" as if people are always reliable of telling the truth 100% of the time GMs lie as much as we do. They aren't any different. They have their dirty secrets they hide as much as anyone else

    Only God knows how one can remain that bitter and crude for so long

    they always say "we will send dis 2 our superiors" to most of every suggestion they reply to. And apparently, all of them get denied. Why is it that every other server gets things the community craves for, but Redbana doesn't? It's because they don't send it. Simple as that. Everything doesn't go through T3 to begin with. Though not everything would be approved, some things will. But nothing has
    Originally posted by SiouXsie View Post

    Haven't you even noticed that if we get bugs we fixed it easily? Some may say that there shouldn't be bugs in the first place upon release, but not everyone is perfect.
    I don't mean that other servers haven't tried, but the fix that we provide for our servers will soon be applied on other servers as well.. Honestly those other servers should even thank us.
    Though I know that you guys would put up Windows 8 issue here.. then again do the other servers already have the Windows 8 issue fixed?

    How about those Beat Up Lv3 songs that you guys suggested, do you see it on other servers before other than KAU or SEA?
    NO! We're the first international server to acquire it.
    Originally posted by Ricardo View Post
    so all you have to show is fixing bugs that are mostly small,irrelevant, and unnecessary to fix and adding in level 3 songs

    i see. keep up the good work pal
    Originally posted by Ricardo View Post
    There has been many things done for this server as a whole, but that's not the point. What's been done in the past year or two is what I'm talking about. You can run and ramble about all the little things you do, but you all neglect the essential things.
    I am confused o-o
    Last edited by Fae; 12-30-2012, 05:37 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Makoto
    replied
    Originally posted by SiouXsie View Post
    I've just point out a few, but if you can't find some of those then you're just talking with your eyes close.
    There has been many things done for this server as a whole, but that's not the point. What's been done in the past year or two is what I'm talking about. You can run and ramble about all the little things you do, but you all neglect the essential things.

    You'll ban someone for glitching, but when it comes to hacking, it doesn't get done.

    You'll ban someone for "harassment"(which honestly isn't. A fight =/= harassment)

    But when it comes to someone doing something such as CPBP reset, if they're one of the many asskissers that stay on GMs' **** all the time, the report will be ignored while the staff goes around doing small stuff to make it out as if they're doing something that good


    i can already imagine hellqueer going like "oh girl u got him see i told u he wuz stupid he dont listen he dumb as ****"

    edit: when I say you, I'm referring to the staff as a whole. Not specifically you

    Leave a comment:


  • Oddbrother
    replied
    Originally posted by SiouXsie View Post
    I've just point out a few, but if you can't find some of those then you're just talking with your eyes close.
    Looks like it's time to dust off the ol' trusty Search button again.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X